Please note the Baldwin & Lyons subsidiaries Protective Insurance Company, Sagamore Insurance Company, and Protective Specialty Insurance Company are rebranding under the name Protective Insurance. All of our respective products, policies and services will remain unchanged.

Report a Claim Online

Protective offers convenient online reporting. Simply fill out our online claim reporting form and one of Protective's skilled adjusters will contact you to continue processing your claim.

Report a vehicle claim online 

Report a workers’ compensation claim online 

 

Report a Claim by Phone or Email

Our claim reporting center is available 24 hours a day, seven days a week.

Vehicle Claims

P: (800) 626-8381
F: (317) 636-3483
claims@protectiveinsurance.com

Workers' Compensation Claims

P: (800) 479-0981
F: (317) 715-9639
NewWCClaims@protectiveinsurance.com

Work Accident Claims

P: (800) 475-2203
NewWCClaims@protectiveinsurance.com