Contact Us

Company Headquarters:

Protective Insurance Company
111 Congressional Blvd., Suite 500
Carmel, IN 46032
(800) 644-5501

Mailing address:

P.O. Box 2000
Carmel, IN 46082-2000

Connect on Twitter: @ProtectiveIns

Report a Claim

Protective offers convenient options for you to easily report your claim.

  1. Call us at the appropriate number listed below during regular business hours to speak to one of our specialized adjusters.
  2. Fill out a simple online form and one of our adjusters will contact you to continue processing your claim.

REPORT A CLAIM   Our claim reporting center can be reached from 8 a.m. to 5 p.m. Eastern time.

Physical Damage/Non-Trucking Liability Claims

Report an auto claim online 

Medium Fleet Trucking, Independent Contractor and Public Transportation:

P: (800) 626-8381, ext. 5074
F: (317) 636-3483

Large Fleet Trucking:

P: (317) 636-9800

Workers' Compensation Claims

P: (800) 479-0981
F: (317) 715-9639
Report a workers' compensation claim online

Work Accident Claims

P: (800) 475-2203




Large Fleet Trucking

P: (800) 644-5501, ext. 2582 or 2584

Medium Fleet Trucking

Contact your agent or account executive.

Public Transportation

Contact your agent.

Independent Contractor

P: (800) 626-8381




Fleet Trucking and Independent Contractor Program
Direct Sales


Matt Thompson
(800 644-5501, ext. 2684

View additional contact info for Large Fleet Trucking

Fleet Trucking, Independent Contractor Program and Public Transportation
Agency Marketing


Stacy Renz
(800 644-5501, ext. 2570

View additional contact info for our agency marketing team


Send an email to Protective using our online form.